What is the best type of eyeliner [out of cream, gel, liquid, felt or pencil] to get smooth but dark lines?

I normally use L'Oreal HiP Color Truth Cream Eyeliner, but have always bought it in the Blackest Black, which I haven't been able to find [even online]. I've found black, but it has an almost brown tint to it. If I wanted brown, I would have bought brown. =D I've also tried Physicians Formula Felt Pen Eyeliner but it's not water proof, so it smudges quickly and makes me look like a raccoon.





I'm looking for an eyeliner that goes on fairly easy, goes on smoothly [doesn't clump or smudge or give you that ';melting'; look]. I'm not sure what the actual difference between the four eyeliners - besides the obvious texture [in all honesty, I've never seen / used the gel - I've only heard of it].





Anyway, what I am asking is: What is a good eyeliner, that's easy to apply, dries quickly enough so it doesn't smudge, and that I can get fairly dark without having to draw or re-do the line more than once or twice? Any suggestions / brands are welcome. Thank you. =DWhat is the best type of eyeliner [out of cream, gel, liquid, felt or pencil] to get smooth but dark lines?
The best gel liner: MAC fluid lines they're waterproof and go good on the waterline as well as upper lash line


The best cream liner: The l'oreal one you've used... I know MAC pro has a cream liner but I never used it.


Liquid: Personally I like the wet n wild one. I like the super thin fine brush but perstidge has a good one as well.


Felt: never used . ;p


Pencil: Urban decay 24/7


^ best liner I've ever used.What is the best type of eyeliner [out of cream, gel, liquid, felt or pencil] to get smooth but dark lines?
I think the pencil goes on great. But it depends on the brand. If you buy eyeliner and it won't go on good try to sharpen it.





So to answer your question: Pencil :)
I use MAC in Black track fluidline which always gives me the darkest line, you do have to use a brush to apply it but its worth it
i use the stencil from revlon colorstay, it works really good and doesn't fade as i am a thick wearer of it.
cream liner is best
you could try using a primer on your eye and under your eye before applying eyeliner. i find that prevents any smearing or smudging of liners.





Kohl pencils go on easily and offer a more... smudged look instead of a crisp line that creams and liquids can offer. These tend to me messier though.





I would suggest for lower lashes getting a cream or gel liner. and for upper lashes, liquid or cream looks nice (liquid if you prefer a cleaner look, cream if you like a look that is clean but not so sharp and that can me smudged a bit)





go to a store and try them out on your hand, see what you like most.
cover girl has some pens that are similar to the L'Oreal you used. i haven't used the L'Oreal but the cover girl works great for me.





this is what i use: http://www.covergirl.com/products/produc鈥?/a>


it goes on just like you are drawing with a marker, if you mess up you can easily wipe it off (quickly though) but once it dries its water/ tear proof





this is the one that i think is like the L'Oreal: http://www.covergirl.com/products/produc鈥?/a>


i have used this one before also but i tend to mess up and this is harder to fix because it dries basically instantly